Map
Index
Random
Help
th

QuoteRef: demiRA5_1979

topics > all references > ThesaHelp: references c-d



ThesaHelp:
ACM references a-e
ThesaHelp:
references c-d
Topic:
mathematical proof as a social process
Topic:
program proving is infeasible
Topic:
resourceful, redundant systems for reliability
Topic:
trust
Topic:
sensitivity of software to change
Topic:
specification is infeasible
Topic:
program source as truth
Group:
engineering
Topic:
safety critical systems
Group:
psychology
Topic:
probability assessment

Reference

DeMillo, R.A., Lipton, R.J., Perlis, A.J., "Social processes and proofs of theorems and programs ", Communications of the ACM , 22, 5, pp. 271-280 , May 1979 . Google

Quotations
272 ;;Quote: mathematicians' errors are corrected by other mathematicians, not by formal logic
273 ;;Quote: when a mathematician grasps a proof, he tries it out on his colleagues; it is not absolute
273 ;;Quote: if a mathematical proof is believed, it is internalized, paraphrased
274 ;;Quote: a believable theorem gets used
274 ;;Quote: the truth of a theorem is established through transformations, generalizations, use, and connections
275 ;;Quote: a verification of a program must be accepted blindly without the social processes of mathematical proofs
277 ;;Quote: if we feel that something is provably right then redundancies are removed
277+;;Quote: failure of a system without redundancies is massive and uncontrolled; like the Titanic
277 ;;Quote: a verified program is provably corrected but not reliable and trustworthy; no information about limits
277 ;;Quote: since a program is a human artifact it will contain imperfections and can never be verified
278 ;;Quote: a trivial, minute change can wreak havoc in a massive system; like the time traveler who damages a butterfly
278 ;;Quote: a verification may not be transferable to any other program; prevents social processes
278 ;;Quote: a program is the only complete description of the program's behavior
278 ;;Quote: the construction of symbolic structures uses resources; can be impossibly long if care is not taken
279 ;;Quote: how do engineers create reliable structures from imperfect mechanisms
279+;;Quote: people must act without sufficient knowledge


Related Topics up

ThesaHelp: ACM references a-e (259 items)
ThesaHelp: references c-d (337 items)
Topic: mathematical proof as a social process (14 items)
Topic: program proving is infeasible (46 items)
Topic: resourceful, redundant systems for reliability (35 items)
Topic: trust (16 items)
Topic: sensitivity of software to change (44 items)
Topic: specification is infeasible (46 items)
Topic: program source as truth (17 items)
Group: engineering   (30 topics, 302 quotes)
Topic: safety critical systems (32 items)
Group: psychology   (9 topics, 303 quotes)
Topic: probability assessment (26 items)

Collected barberCB 4/82
Copyright © 2002-2008 by C. Bradford Barber. All rights reserved.
Thesa is a trademark of C. Bradford Barber.