Map
Index
Random
Help
Topics
th

Topic: causal theory of names

topics > Group: naming



Topic:
denoting phrases and definite descriptions
Topic:
names as abbreviations for descriptions
Topic:
names as rigid designators
Topic:
names independent of objects
Topic:
naming by pointing or recognition
Topic:
objects without names
Topic:
proper names

Summary

The causal theory of names states that a name denotes an item if there is a causal chain of reference-preserving links. There is an initial 'baptism' and then the name is passed from person to person. There may be an explicit act of pointing to identify the named object.

Sear's argues against the causal theory of names and argues for names as description. For example, suppose you know that Thales was a Greek philosopher. Perhaps Aristotle actually used 'Thales' for a well digger, and someone passed the name incorrectly. 'Thales' still refers to the philosopher instead of the well digger.

The most important names are for frequent, personal contacts. Though learned from other people, a name does not depend on a causal chain. (cbb 12/00)

Subtopic: causal theory of names up

Quote: the causal theory of names states that a name denotes an item if there is a causal chain of reference-preserving links; e.g., dubbing [»evanG_1973]
Quote: naming by an initial 'baptism' and then passed from person to person with an intension to keep the reference fixed [»kripSA_1980]
Quote: the name of a baby is spread by a chain of using the name in sorts of talk [»kripSA_1980]
Quote: Feynman is identified by a chain of communication back to Feynman himself; not by a declarative ceremony in private [»kripSA_1980]
Quote: in the casual theory of names, reference is fixed by intentional content
Quote: in Kripke's casual theory of names, each speaker must intend to refer to the same object as the person who taught the name [»searJR_1983]

Subtopic: problems with causal theory up

Quote: names as description is primary over the causal theory because only the former guarantees a fixed reference
Quote: the causal theory of names is incorrect; e.g., a tribe where every name is known by ostension and hence description [»searJR_1983]
Quote: the causal theory of names sets no constraints on the reference; e.g., 'Aristotle' might refer to a bar stool if that's where the chain lead to [»searJR_1983]
Quote: Madagascar originally referred to the mainland until Marco Polo accidentally used it for an island; the casual chain is not sufficient [»searJR_1983]
Quote: suppose someone only knows that Thales was a Greek philosopher but Aristotle actually used 'Thales' for a well digger; 'Thales' still wouldn't be the well digger [»searJR_1983]
Quote: Kripke's casual theory of names only reaches to the baptism of an object, but not the object itself [»searJR_1983]
Quote: say two babies are swapped at birth; then the baby dubbed with a name is not the person indicated by the name; intention part of names [»evanG_1973]
Quote: can use a proper name even though no causal connection to an object; e.g., M Street in Washington or the names of numbers [»searJR_1983]
Quote: the causal relation of names lies between the item's states and doings and the speaker's body of information; not dubbing [»evanG_1973]
Quote: consider an urn containing mathematical proofs and signed by Ibn Khan; "Khan proved that.." but could be a scribe [»evanG_1973]
Quote: say an identical twin impersonates a slightly known person; then our knowledge is about the twin and not the original person [»evanG_1973]

Subtopic: limits of causual chains up

Quote: the causal chain of communication for naming is simply an external view of names that are known via others [»searJR_1983]
Quote: could talk about 'Plotinus' even though only heard his name mentioned; but the reference is parasitic on other speakers [»searJR_1983]
Quote: proper names can have prominent uses not based on acquaintance; constrained regardless of chain of communication, e.g., 'Japan' could not refer to a butterfly [»searJR_1983]
Quote: the most important names are for frequent, personal contacts; though learned from other people, a reference does not depend on others
[»searJR_1983]


Related Topics up

Topic: denoting phrases and definite descriptions (21 items)
Topic: names as abbreviations for descriptions (35 items)
Topic: names as rigid designators (43 items)
Topic: names independent of objects (34 items)
Topic: naming by pointing or recognition (13 items)
Topic: objects without names (7 items)
Topic: proper names
(35 items)

Updated barberCB 4/04
Copyright © 2002-2008 by C. Bradford Barber. All rights reserved.
Thesa is a trademark of C. Bradford Barber.